What is Human Capability Assurance?

Human Capability Assurance can be defined as: the systematic identification, maintenance and testing of the human knowledge, skills and judgement an organisation needs in order to supervise, challenge and, where necessary, operate independently of its AI systems.

From When a Human Is in the Loop, Are They Really in Command?

Why is it needed?

Governance structures alone cannot guarantee meaningful human command. The organisation must also maintain the human capability required to make those structures work.

AI oversight depends on humans who can recognise implausible outputs, understand the context, challenge assumptions and intervene when circumstances fall outside the system's competence. A human can remain formally responsible while becoming progressively less capable of exercising that responsibility.

From When a Human Is in the Loop, Are They Really in Command? and If AI Takes Over the Work of the Apprentice, Where Will Tomorrow’s Expert Come From?

Is a human in the loop enough?

Putting a human in the loop is a procedural safeguard. Ensuring that the human has the capability to exercise independent judgement is a command safeguard.

In military settings the stakes are exceptional, but the underlying management problem is familiar. A hospital, bank, engineering company, law firm or public authority can all retain a nominal human decision-maker while allowing the underlying human expertise to weaken.

From When a Human Is in the Loop, Are They Really in Command?

What question does it ask?

The central management question therefore changes. It is no longer only, “What work can AI do?” It also becomes, “What human capability does this work currently help to create, and how will we create that capability after the work has been automated?”

From If AI Takes Over the Work of the Apprentice, Where Will Tomorrow’s Expert Come From?

Where is it explored?

Succession: AI, Human Capability and the Future of Human Command proposes the concept of Human Capability Assurance alongside a layered approach to checking, securing and controlling the work of AI. Together, these aim to help us benefit from AI while keeping people capable of directing it and dealing with problems when they arise. The book includes:

  • Chapter 5 — Human Capability Assurance
  • Appendix A — Human Capability Assurance Operating Framework
  • Appendix E — Organisational Human Capability Assurance Audit