The central principle

The specification is not simply a brief that disappears once work starts. It is the project’s working guide and the basis of its final acceptance review. Establish the requirements before work begins, then compare the finished work with those same requirements.

Step 1: choose a task-specific specification

Start with a generic template and adapt it to the task:

  • Research: question, scope, sources, evidence quality, synthesis and conclusions.
  • Article or report: purpose, readership, structure, accuracy, sources, editing and presentation.
  • Product development: need, competing solutions, requirements, design alternatives, testing and acceptance.
  • Investigation: questions, evidence handling, alternative explanations, traceability and findings.
  • Business proposal: objectives, options, assumptions, costs, risks and recommendations.
  • Project management: scope, responsibilities, milestones, outputs, risks and quality checks.
  • AI-assisted task: permissions, required inputs, checking, handling of uncertainty and human approval.

Step 2: distinguish mandatory from desirable

The project owner identifies the requirements without which the work cannot be accepted. A separate menu of desirable activities might include brainstorming, competitor research, consultation, case studies, alternative approaches, cost-benefit analysis and extra verification.

This avoids two errors: leaving important work out and making small tasks unnecessarily complicated.

Step 3: define evidence and acceptance

Each major requirement needs three linked elements: the requirement itself; the evidence showing that it has been fulfilled; and the acceptance standard.

Example: instead of “check competitors”, specify “compare three relevant alternatives using price, capabilities and limitations; cite sources; explain the comparison’s implications”.

Step 4: carry out the work

Use the specification as a working reference, not just a starting document. AI may assist with research, generating alternatives, creating drafts and performing structured comparisons. The originator must still examine what AI produces and document important decisions.

If scope or standards change, record the modification, reasons and approval.

Step 5: verify independently

Check calculations, sources, factual claims, internal consistency and coverage of requirements. Where helpful, a second AI can compare the completed output with the specification and supporting material.

Independent AI checking can expose omissions but may also introduce errors. The checking result should be treated as a challenge to investigate, not an automatic verdict.

Step 6: carry out the final review

Return to the approved specification and identify every mandatory requirement as satisfied, partially satisfied or not satisfied. Record supporting evidence and unresolved exceptions. A human decision-maker can then accept the work, accept it subject to corrections or return it for further work.

Suggested review-sheet headings

Project name | Requirement or activity | Mandatory/desirable | Evidence and acceptance criterion | Final result | Corrections or decision.

The headings above can be reused for a short assignment or expanded for a major project.

Downloadable working template

The companion Word document “AI-Assisted Project Specification and Assurance Method” contains task-specific examples, a list of desirable activities and a reusable review sheet. It is intended to be copied and tailored before work begins.

Download project specification and review checklist (Word)

The method can be summarised as: Specify → Select → Execute → Verify → Review. Its central advantage is that the originator knows what good work must look like before submission.

For further information: ai-humancapability.com

About the author

R T Scanlon is the author of three books on AI and human capability. He has worked in education, management and other practical roles, and holds an MBA with a dissertation focused on quality assurance.

Meet the author → Books on Amazon → (opens in a new tab) LinkedIn → (opens in a new tab)